Physics case for polarized positrons at the ILC

A short version of the POWER report and its executive summary has been summarized in this quintessence, including the summary table. More details of the listed examples as well as references to the original studies are given in the POWER report.

Couplings structure:

Coupling structure in e+e- The dominant processes in e+ e- experiments are annihilation (s-channel) and scattering (t-channel) processes. In annihilation diagrams the helicities of the incoming beams are coupled to each other by the spin of the exchanged particle(s) in the s-channel (in the Standard Model only J=1 possible).

In t-channel diagrams the helicities of the incoming beams are directly coupled to the chirality of the (new) particles produced. If both beams are polarized, it is possible to adjust independently the polarizations of both beams. This ability provides unique possibilities for probing directly the properties of the produced particles.

Statistical issues:

Statistical gain in ALR In processes where only (axial-) vector interactions are contributing in e+e- annihilation, the cross section with polarized beams can be expressed by the left-right asymmetry, the unpolarized cross section, and two beam polarization-dependent factors, the effective polarization and a prefactor that is proportional to the number of interacting particles.

Polarized e+ with P(e+)=60% in addition to P(e-)=90% rise the effective polarization up to 97% compared with only P(e-)=90%. The precision in the left--right asymmetry is given by the polarimeter resolution; it is improved by more than a factor 3 if polarized e+ are provided. Similarly, the number of interacting particles can only be enhanced with the polarization of both beams, with (P(e-),P(e+))=(80%,60%) by about a factor 1.5. These pure statistical factors are, for instance, important for top and Higgs studies.

Polarized positrons in top and Higgs studies, sqrt(s) up to 500 GeV:

Statistical gain in top Precise measurements of the properties of the top quark will greatly advance our understanding of the underlying physics at the quantum level. The ILC provides an ideal tool to probe the couplings of the top quark to the electroweak gauge bosons, in particular the neutral electroweak couplings are accessible only at lepton colliders.

Polarization effects have been studied at the top threshold and in the continuum. The measurement of the left-right asymmetry is crucial. Using both beam polarized (P(e-),P(e+))=(80%,60%) compared with (80%,0) leads to an improvement factor of about 3, for pure statistical reasons as explained before.

Separation of Higgs production With 95% C.L. a light Higgs mass below 207 GeV is predicted. If mH=130 GeV both dominant production processes, Higgs-strahlung and WW-fusion, have comparable cross sections. Using both beam polarized leads to an improvement factor of about 4 for the separation of both processes.

The top-Yukawa coupling plays a keyrole in understanding the mechanism of electroweak symmetry breaking. At the LHC a precision of about 20% is expected. At the ILC with 500 GeV, the measurement is particularly challenging due to kinematical limitations. A precision of 24% for mH=120 GeV for unpolarized beams is expected at the ILC. The improvement factor is about 2.5 when using (P(e-),P(e+))=(80%,60%) compared with (80%,0%) and will be rather substantial for the achievable precision.

Polarized positrons in new physics searches:

Supersymmetry

Quantum numbers of selectrons One of the most promising candidates for physics beyond the SM is supersymmetry. This new symmetry predicts that every SM particle has a SUSY partner that has the same quantum numbers as their SM partner, with the exception of the spin. Electroweak precision tests predict that at least some SUSY particles should be accessible at sqrt(2)=500 GeV. To really establish supersymmetry experimentally, all model assumptions and implications have to be verified.

For instance, the chiral quantum numbers of the scalar partners of the electron/positron have to be verified. This association can only be directly tested in the production of the pairs sel+L sel-R. Even a highly polarized electron beam may not be sufficient to separate this process from sel+R sel-R, since both can be produced with almost identical cross sections and have the same decay. Applying simultaneously polarized positrons, the pairs get different cross sections, can be isolated and the properties of the particles can be tested separately.

Smuon masses in the continuum A striking tool at the linear collider are threshold scans, leading, for instance, to mass measurements of SUSY particles with a precision even below the per mil level. Since threshold scans cost luminosity, it is important to optimize the needed energy steps a priori via measurements in the continuum. An accuracy of 2 per mil can already be reached in the continuum if the dominant WW background has been suppressed.
Using (P(e-),P(e+))=(+80%,-60%) compared with (+80%,0%) leads to a improvement in WW suppression by about a factor of 2. Therefore positron polarization can be substantial to observe all needed kinematical edges.
Sneutrino resonance The polarization of both beams allows us to probe directly the spins of particles produced in resonances. In a R-parity-violating SUSY model a spin-0 particle with only left-handed couplings, is produced in the s-channel. The SM background is strongly suppressed and one gets a S/B~11 for (P(e-),P(e+))=(-80%,-60%), whereas for unpolarized beams as well as for (P(e-),P(e+))=(-80%,0) the ratio is only about S/B~4.

Conversely, in the case of a spin-1 resonance, e.g. the Z' particle in the SSM model (right plot), the corresponding resonance peak would be strongest for the LR configuration, with a similar polarization dependence as the SM background.

Extra gauge bosons in indirect searches

Zprime couplings Extra neutral gauge bosons Z' can be probed by their virtual effects on cross sections and asymmetries. For energies below the Z' resonance, measurements of fermion-pair production are sensitive to the ratio of Z' couplings and Z' mass. Positron-beam polarization with (P(e-),P(e+))=(80%,60%) would improve the measurement of the b bar{b} couplings of the Z' --even without knowledge of the Z' mass-- by about a factor 1.5 compared with P(e-)=80% only.

The crucial point is the fact that the systematic errors can be significantly reduced when both beams are polarized.

Contact interactions in indirect searches

Model-independent bounds in cI In Bhabha scattering the four-fermion contact interactions are parametrized by three parameters (epsilon_RR, epsilon_LR, epsilon_LL). The t-channel contributions depend only on epsilon_LR, whereas the s-channel contribution depends only on pairs (epsilon_RR,epsilon_LR), (epsilon_LR,epsilon_LL). The observables are the unpolarized cross section, the left-right asymmetry and the forward-backward asymmetry. The study was done at sqrt(s)=500 GeV.

In order to derive model-independent bounds it is necessary to have both beams polarized.

Transversely-polarized beams for new physics searches:

Extra dimensions in indirect searches:

Extra dimensions Transversely-polarized beams are sensitive to non-standard interactions, which are not of the current--current type, such as those mediated by spin-2 gravitons or (pseudo)scalar exchanges, even in indirect searches. With transversely-polarized beams (both beams have to be polarized) an azimuthal asymmetry can be constructued that uniquely distinguishes, for instance, different extra-dimension models up to >= 3 TeV.

Representative examples are the models of Randall-Sundrum (RS) and Arkani-Hamed, Dimopoulos, Dvali (ADD). The new asymmetry vanishes for both the SM and the RS scenario, so that a non-zero value unambiguously signals the ADD graviton exchange. Study was done at sqrt(s)=500 GeV.

Polarized positrons in precision tests of the Standard Model:

At GigaZ:

Giga Z Measuring accurately the left--right asymmetry allows a determination of the effective weak mixing angle sin^2 theta_eff with the highest precision. However, in order to exploit the gain in statistics at GigaZ, the relative uncertainties on the beam polarization have to be kept below 0.1%.

The ultimate precision cannot be reached with Compton polarimetry, but by using a modified Blondel scheme, which requires the polarization of both beams. One gains about 1 order of magnitude in the accuracy of sin^2 theta_eff, when using (P(e-),P(e+))=(80%,60%) instead of (80%,0%).

Higgs bounds at Giga Z Within the SM, the improvement in the accuracy of sin^2 theta_eff by about 1 order of magnitude, has a dramatic effect on the indirect determination of the Higgs-boson mass. Because of the gain of about 1 order of magnitude, the bounds on the Higgs mass in the SM improve by also about 1 order of magnitude.

Comparing the indirect constraints on the Higgs-boson mass with a direct measurement of m_h provides a sensitive test of the electroweak theory at the quantum level. Such a highly sensitive consistency test of the model may also possibly point towards large new-physics scales.

SUSY bounds at Giga Z The precision measurement of sin^2 theta_eff yields also strong constraints on the allowed range for the SUSY parameters, here the mass parameter m_1/2 in a specific model, the CMSSM. The allowed range of m_1/2 is reduced by a factor of about 5 when using (P(e-),P(e+))=(80%,60%) instead of (80%,0%).

Such stringent bounds in Supersymmetry due to the large increase in the precision of sin^2 theta_eff will constitute, in analogy to the SM case, a powerful consistency test of SUSY at the quantum level and may be crucial to constrain SUSY parameters that are not directly experimentally accessible and to outline the required high-energy stage of the ILC.

At sqrt(s)=500 GeV with longitudinally- and transversely-polarized beams:

Triple gauge couplings Longitudinally- as well as transversely-polarized beams are also important for high-precision tests of the SM at sqrt(s)=500 GeV. A powerful method for testing the electroweak gauge group in the SM consists in parametrizing the gauge-boson self-interactions in the most general way with 14 parameters of the triple gauge couplings (TGC).

Longitudinally-polarized e- and e+ beams are sufficient for most TGCs: for determining the TGCs, one gains about a factor 1.8 with both beams longitudinally polarized, compared with having only polarized electrons. However, transversely-polarized beams provide the unique access to one specific TGC. Both beams polarized are therefore needed to fully exploit the TGCs as sensitive test of the electroweak gauge group.

Recent talks and proceedings about polarized beams at the ILC:

LCWS05 at SLAC:
Nello Paver, talk Positron Polarization at the International Linear Collider and proceedings
Uriel Nauenberg, talk The importance of e+ polarization
G. Moortgat-Pick, summary talk Polarized e- and e+ at the ILC and proceedings

Snowmass'05
G. Moortgat-Pick, talks Polarized e- and e+ at the ILC -- Top and Higgs, Polarized e- and e+ at the ILC -- Supersymmetry, and proceedings

Aspen '05
G. Moortgat-Pick, talk Polarization of both beams at the ILC

POSIPOL, 2006
G. Moortgat-Pick, talk The physics aspects of polarized e+ and proceedings

Lectures about spin physics

LC Summer School at Ambleside, 2003:
G. Moortgat-Pick, Beam Polarisation at the LC

Cockcroft Institute, Daresbury, 2006:
D. Barber, Introduction to Spin Polarisation
G.Moortgat-Pick, Spin Dynamics and Polarization



Gudi Moortgat-Pick
Last modified: 21-August-2006